Derek Jeter vs. Justin Timberlake
The two greatest American bachelors still on the prowl today.
John Mayer used to give them a run for their money, but women have scorned him since he referenced Jessica Simpson as "sexual napalm."
So, let's settle the debate once and for all.
Who has dated hotter girls? Jeter or Timberlake?
I'll compare their five hottest girlfriends (in my opinion of course) to determine the ultimate winner.