Copyright (c) 2007 Stetson University College of Law
Stetson Law Review
ARTICLE: PEER REVIEW AND PUBLICATION: LESSONS FOR LAWYERS*
* This Article was developed from a talk entitled "Scrutinizing Peer Review" given at the National Institute of Justice Conference on Science and the Law held in St. Petersburg, Florida, in September 2005. It appears here by invitation.
36 Stetson L. Rev. 789
The phrase "peer review" connotes the evaluation ("review") of scientific or other scholarly work by others presumed to have expertise in the relevant field ("peers"). Specifically, and most to the present purpose, it refers to the evaluation of submitted manuscripts to determine what work is published in professional journals and what books are published by academic presses (in which context it is also called "refereeing," "editorial peer review," or "pre-publication peer review"). 2 Occasionally, however, the phrase is used in a much broader sense, to cover the whole long-run history of the scrutiny of a scientist's work within the scientific community, and of others' efforts to build on it, 3 a long-run process of which peer review in the narrower sense is only a small part.
These two conceptions of peer review, the narrow and the broad, both came into play in the arguments over the admissibility of the plaintiffs' expert testimony in Daubert. 4 In 1989, granting Merrell Dow's motion for summary judgment on the ground that the Dauberts' proffered causation evidence was inadmissible, the District Court had stressed that "none of the published studies show a statistically significant association between the use of Bendectin and birth defects"; 5 and affirming this decision in 1991, observing that "no published epidemiological study had demonstrated a statistically significant association between Bendectin and birth defects," and that "the normal peer[-]review process ... is one of the hallmarks of reliable scientific investigation," ...
If you are interested in obtaining a lexis.com® ID and Password, please contact us at 1-(800)-227-4908 or visit us at http://www.lexisnexis.com/.