Carbon Limits and Energy for America's Renewal Act
The Carbon Limits and Energy for America's Renewal Act is a Senate climate bill S. 2877 introduced by Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-WA) and Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) on December 11, 2009, which embodies a “cap-and-refund” approach to addressing climate change. The Act would create a nationwide limit on greenhouse gases by capping total emissions and requiring major polluters to buy “allowances” for each ton of greenhouse pollution produced: 75% of the revenue generated from the allowances would go to American households, and the remaining 25% of revenue is reserved for reducing greenhouse gas emissions, investments in renewable energy technology, climate adaptation, and other purposes.
According to Sen. Cantwell: "A growing number of researchers and consumer groups have been examining the relative benefits of a greenhouse gas reduction policy that focuses on safeguarding and empowering consumers. A properly structured climate policy will put cash in consumers’ pockets and provide the necessary capital to make America’s homes and communities more efficient and less polluting."
In promoting a cap and dividend policy without carbon offsets, stronger carbon limits that do not interfere with the Clean Air Act, and increased funding for renewables over fossil fuels, the bill differs from the financial market carbon trading plan promoted by the Clean Energy Jobs and American Power Act, introduced in May 2010 by Senators John Kerry and Joseph Lieberman.
The bill would require the President to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions relative to 2005 levels by 20% by 2020, 30% by 2025, 42% by 2030, and 83% by 2050, through a gradually declining cap. The cap works by limiting the amount of fossil fuel carbon that producers and importers of coal, natural gas, and oil can sell into the U.S. economy, generating revenue from the carbon permits bought by producers and importers of coal, natural gas, and oil. (In other words, a power plant that burns coal does not buy carbon permits; it is paid by the mining company that mined the coal.) The bill's authors argue that the CLEAR Act’s “upstream” point of regulation means that only 2,000 to 3,000 fossil fuel producers and importers will face any new compliance obligations, greatly reducing any regulatory bureaucracy.
Carbon permit prices will be determined by the bidding process among fossil fuel companies participating in monthly auctions. Only entities with a compliance obligation are eligible to participate in auctions—no Wall street traders or financial speculators are allowed in. To minimize price volatility, a price collar governs carbon permit prices.
The Cantwell-Collins bill does not allow for carbon offsets, so that they are not used in place of domestic reductions in fossil fuel consumption, a strong criticism of the Kerry-Boxer bill, S.1733, and the House-passed Waxman-Markey bill, H.R. 2454.
Cap and Dividend
75% of auction revenues are given back to consumers directly each month on an equal per capita basis to offset energy cost increases, known as cap and dividend and bypassing a cap and trade market. Average annual refunds for a family of four are estimated to be approximately $1000. The dividend will consumers cover potential ncreases in the price of fosisl fuels, and the bill's authors estimate that 80% of the American public will incur no net costs, and the lowest income population will receive net positive benefits. The remaining 20% percent – the highest income earners—will see less than a 0.3% decrease in income.
Clean Energy Reinvestment Trust Fund
25% of auction revenues go into the Clean Energy Reinvestment Trust Fund to pay for additional greenhouse gas emissions reductions, low‐carbon energy investment, climate change adaptation, and related regional economic adjustment projects.
Carbon reduction Estimates
This cap on carbon emissions, combined with spending from the Clean Energy Reinvestment Trust Fund, is designed to achieve the following goals for reducing carbon pollution:
- 20% lower global warming pollution by 2020 (relative to 2005)
- 30% lower global warming pollution by 2025 (relative to 2005)
- 42% lower global warming pollution by 2030 (relative to 2005)
- 83% lower global warming pollution by 2050 (relative to 2005)
These goals are achieved by the specified carbon reductions and reductions in additional greenhouse gases that harm the atmosphere, such as methane and hydroflorocarbons, and by investment in carbon sequestration projects.
Articles and resources
- J. Scott Holladay and Michael A. Livermore, [http://www.policyintegrity.org/documents/ClearandTheEconomy.pdf "CLEAR & The Economy: Innovation, Equity, and Job Creation"] NYU Institute for Policy Integrity Policy Brief No. 6, April 2010.
- "Climate Policy that Pays Short and Long-Term Dividends" Cantwell.senate.gov, December 2009.
- S. 1733 "Clean Energy Jobs and American Power Act"
- "How the CLEAR Act Works" Cantwell.senate.gov, accessed May 2010.
Related SourceWatch articles
- Waxman-Markey Climate Bill
- Clean Energy Jobs and American Power Act
- Carbon trading
- Coal moratorium
- Cap and dividend
- Carbon fees
- Carbon trading
- Emissions trading
- Environmental justice and coal
- Electric Utility Cap and Trade Act
- External costs of coal
- Our Country Deserves Better
- United States and Post-Kyoto Protocol negotiations on greenhouse gas emissions
- The impact of global warming on the U.S. energy sector
- U.S. coal politics
- "S. 2877 Carbon Limits and Energy for America's Renewal Act Sen. Cantwell, introduced December 2009.
- Donny Shaw, "The Battle Over a Global Warming Bill", OpenCongress, February 6, 2008.
- Kate Galbraith, "Combative Start to Senate Climate Hearings," "Green Inc" New York Times blog, July 7, 2009.
- Kate Sheppard, "Boxer and Reid delay Senate action on climate bill until September 6," Grist.org, July 9, 2009.
- "Senate Climate Change Bill Delayed Until September," Environment News Service, July 9, 2009.
- Sabrina Eaton, "Cap-and-trade plan fuels political debate; questions and answers on some of the major issues," The Plain Dealer (Cleveland, Ohio), July 13, 2009.
- Sam Eaton, "Oil industry report targets climate bill," Marketplace (text of radio report), August 24, 2009.
- Kate Sheppard, "Lobby horse: Majority of 'Energy Citizens' rallies organized by oil-industry lobbyists," Grist.org, August 21, 2009.
- Steve Lynn, "San Juan County energy workers rally against legislation," The Daily Times (Farmington, New Mexico), August 22, 2009.
- "'Energy Citizens' rally vs. climate, energy bill," Associated Press, August 31, 2009.