Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:
- Leave Well Enough Alone (Bronze): Experienced a brief, yet horrifying transformation.
- Why is My Older Brother Laughing? (Bronze): Encountered a shipload of references to the previous Monkey Island games.
- The Sounds of Science (Bronze): Heard DeSinge treating four different patients.
- Bats Right, Throws Lame (Bronze): Repeatedly Threw Things... Kinda.
- Is That a Pox On Your Face, Or Are You Just Angry To See Me? (Bronze): Experience the effects of the Pox on the charming inhabitants of Flotsam.
- The Legend of LeFlay (Silver): Quizzed everyone about Morgan LeFlay.
- This Ain't a Library (Silver): Intensely browsed a prominent bookshelf.
- LeChuck Slayer (Silver): Defeated LeChuck (again).
- Use the Source (Silver): Met Deep Gut.
- The Winds of Freedom Blow (Silver): Escaped from Flotsam Island.
- Many Unhappy Returns (Gold): Found Elaine.