Then again, stranger things have happened on set than Emma Roberts channeling her inner muppet. The actress, who plays Madison Montgomery, ditched the dark duds of her witchy Coven role for a coat straight out of Elmo's closet. The 22-year-old was recently spotted in Los Angeles – no strings attached – in the vibrant sheath of red puppet fluff.
It remains unconfirmed whether Roberts will return for American Horror Story's fourth season, but all signs point to future bliss. The actress recently became engaged to her AHS costar, 27-year-old Evan Peters.