Parshios Acharei Mos & Kedoshim
Fun vs. Pleasure
“Where’s the fun in that?” someone might ask reading this week’s parshios.
These deal with forbidden relationships, and then with all sorts of other
activities to be avoided because they reduce holiness, or with activities to
be pursued because they increase holiness. Indeed, it seems as if holiness
is that which results from doing just the opposite of that which provides
the most fun in life.
Therefore, it follows, if one wants to pursue a life of holiness, he or she
has to turn his or her back on fun, just as a person who wants to have fun
has to give up on being a holy person, just as so many have done throughout
the ages. Being mutually exclusive, a person has to choose between one and
the other, and trying to have one’s cake and eat it too can only result in
hypocrisy, as it has over the ages, and as the media keeps revealing.
Given the nature of man, and the world of fun in which he finds himself, we
can understand why a person would choose fun over holiness. More difficult
to understand and appreciate, however, is why an intellectually-sound and
emotionally-balanced person would choose holiness over fun.
The answer comes in one word: Pleasure. However, it will take several to
explain why that is, in fact, the answer. It’s just one of those everyday
ideas that people think they understand, but really don’t, resulting in so
much wasted time, energy, and life, and historically, Divine wrath and world
“That was fun!”
What does a person mean when he says those words?
“No problem, it was my pleasure!”
What does he mean when he says those words?
We rarely have to be thanked for doing something that is fun because fun is
usually all gain and no loss for those who have it. Even when considerable
effort is involved, if it is part of the fun, we think nothing of it and
gladly expend it. Quite the contrary, we usually feel like thanking others
for our experience after the fun is over.
Not necessarily so when it comes to pleasure, which often entails some kind
of personal sacrifice. For example, there are plenty of times when it might
seem more enjoyable to not help someone out, either because we’re tired, or
going the other direction, etc., but we do it anyhow and, remarkably, feel
better about ourselves because we do.
In fact, the more we have to sacrifice to do something meaningful in life,
the better we later tend to feel about ourselves, and, ironically, the more
pleasure we seem to derive from life. Fun and pleasure are not necessarily
mutually exclusive, but they certainly can be.
There is a fundamental reason for this, which has to do with the very
make-up of a human being, who was made in the image of God. What this
amounts to is what we call free will, something we only seem to be able to
exercise when what we want to do comes into conflict with what we feel like
doing, especially if this happens for moral reasons.
We rarely feel like doing the moral thing because the moral thing usually
requires some kind of personal sacrifice that a body does not easily make.
Indeed, often the sacrifice is very uncomfortable, requiring a lot of
personal will power to overcome its resistance in order to do what we know
is the right thing.
Many people either do not have or do not exercise such levels of will, and
often capitulate to what they feel like doing over what they want to do.
However, even though in the short run that might feel good, in the long run,
it denies a person the pleasure from life they ultimately seek, and that
hurts even more than the sacrifice they could have, but did not make.
Unable to live with the pain of doing the immoral thing, they are forced to
either do better next time, or eliminate the idea that what they do is
immoral in the first place. This is what Hitler, ysv”z, did when he tried to
eliminate what he called “two Jewish inventions: circumcision and
conscience.” From his perspective, the Torah took all the fun out of life.
What he, and others before and after him, failed to comprehend was that, as
true as that may have been, it was in exchange for something better:
pleasure. For, though man is capable of sinking to the level of an animal,
or even lower, he cannot remain forever on that level. Eventually, his
Divine spark begins to fight back, souring the fun while in search of true
and lasting pleasure.
The Torah, especially in these parshios, is trying to save us the trouble.
We may not understand why, and many may certainly disagree, but the Torah is
telling us which activities and which relationships bring out the Godly
aspect of man, and which do not. The fact that we do have problems with some
or many of its restrictions only increases the opportunity to use our free
will, which was given to us for this very reason.
Of course, there are people who do not understand the difference between fun
and pleasure, or that there is any difference at all, and they only know the
pain of denying themselves the fun that may result from things that the
Torah rejects. This is too much for them, and for many, the only alternative
is to reject the Torah and the people who advocate it.
The problem is compounded by the fact that the greatest amount of pleasure
from doing the moral, that is, the Torah thing, will only come in the
World-to-Come, and not in this world. As the rabbis explain, all the fun in
the world could never equal even just one hour of pleasure in the
World-to-Come, but try and explain that to someone who does not believe in
Torah, and may not even believe in God.
The tragedy is that, regardless, Creation has its bottom line. Some Torah
violations may have a limited impact on Creation, slowing down world
rectification, but not aborting it. However, others violations of the Torah
by their very nature go against the very fabric and purpose of Creation,
regardless of the “innocence” of the perpetrators.
We have seen the result of that on many occasions. Though the method may
change from one epoch to another, the result is virtually the same: death
and destruction. When the Torah prescribes a serious punishment, even a
deadly one, for a violation of its commandments, it is not out of revenge.
Rather, it is the Torah’s way of saying: This is an extreme violation of
Creation and cannot be tolerated, for Creation’s sake.
Not too long ago, some little child shot and killed his mother. The father
had been showing off some of his personal collection of guns to some
relatives, who had gathered for some happy family occasion, when the young
child just happened to pick one of the guns that happened to be loaded.
Innocently, the child pointed the loaded weapon at the woman and pulled the
trigger, hitting her at close range and killing her.
What a tragedy. How could something so innocent result in something so
sinister? How could someone so guiltless become so guilty? And, even though
the child will never be punishable be the law, he will have a punishing life
once he discovers the truth about his mother’s death. Some terrible results
cannot be avoided even because of innocence and naiveté, not when the
undermine the fabric of Creation and purpose of mankind.
And, nothing is less fun than the world once it begins to fall apart along
its path to correcting that which mankind destroys.
Text Copyright © 2013 by Rabbi Pinchas Winston and Torah.org.