If you gaze far enough into Mindy Kaling’s eyes, you’ll notice a layer of shimmery shadow toward their inner corners and very little color elsewhere. For deep-set eyes like the comedian’s, it’s best to keep shadows light, both in color and application. “Go shiny with peach and beige tones,” says Drew. And instead of applying dark shadow in the crease, contour by sweeping a neutral matte color on the brow bone. “For darker skin tones like Kaling’s, we like M.A.C. Eye Shadow in Brun ($15).