Why Fairness is Essential for Economic Growth
Robert B. Reich
Get ready for the tax wars.
President Obama wants to raise taxes on the rich, setting a minimum tax rate of 30 percent on millionaires (the so-called "Buffett Rule," named after billionaire investor
This should be a no-brainer. Rich Americans are taking home a larger share of America's total income than they have at any time since the 1920s, yet paying the lowest tax rate in more than 30 years.
Meanwhile, the nation faces two giant deficits. Unless the rich pay their fair share of taxes, both will only become worse.
The first is a deficit in public investment. Our roads, bridges, ports, sewer and water systems, and public transportation systems are outmoded. Some are literally falling apart. Meanwhile, many of our schools can't afford textbooks or science labs, students are crowded into classrooms with 30 or more other children, and public colleges and universities are starved for funding.
The other is a budget deficit that's projected to rise into the stratosphere, especially as aging boomers need more health care.
Surely government can be more efficient, the military can be smaller, and pork-barrel spending can be eliminated. But anyone who thinks we can balance the budget without additional revenue doesn't know basic math.
So how can conservatives possibly object to raising taxes on the wealthy?
Easily. I recently debated a conservative economist who claimed people at the top are the entrepreneurs and job creators, as if he were stating a well-accepted economic principle: "If we raise their taxes, we'll have fewer jobs and slower growth."
One of the most pernicious falsehoods you'll hear during the next seven months of political campaigning is that there's a necessary trade-off between fairness and growth.
Our history suggests the opposite. Taxes were far higher on top incomes in the three decades after World War II than they've been since. The top marginal rate was over 70 percent. Even after deductions and credits, rich Americans paid an effective tax rate of over 50 percent. And the distribution of income was far more equal than it has been since.
Yet the American economy grew faster in those years than it's grown since
This wasn't a post-war aberration.
If you need more evidence, consider modern
Higher taxes on the wealthy help finance investments in infrastructure and education, which are vital for growth and the economic prospects of the middle class. In the decades after World War II, we built an interstate highway system and expanded public colleges and universities, and the nation's productivity surged.
Higher taxes on the wealthy can also allow for lower taxes on the middle -- potentially fueling enough middle-class purchasing power to keep the economy growing. As we've seen in recent years, when disposable income is concentrated at the top, the middle class doesn't have enough money to boost the economy.
Finally, concentrated wealth can lead to speculative bubbles, as the rich invest in the same limited class of assets -- whether gold, dotcoms or real estate. When these bubbles pop, the entire economy suffers.
What we should have learned over the last half-century is that growth doesn't trickle down from the top. It percolates upward from working people who are adequately educated, sufficiently rewarded, and who feel they have a fair chance to make it in America.
If anything, the Buffett Rule doesn't go nearly far enough. We should restore tax rates to what they were before 1981, and make the capital-gains rate the same as the rate on ordinary income. There's no good reason why Romney should pay a rate of less than 14 percent on an income of more than
Fairness isn't incompatible with economic growth. It's essential to it.
- Why Europe's Double Dip Could Lead to One in United States
- Why Fairness is Essential for Economic Growth
- Tax Dollars and (Common) Sense
- This Economy Stinks Worse than You Think
- The Decline of Labor and the Future of the Middle Class
- Worker-First Philosophy All Too Rare
- 'Say on Pay' Votes Battle Back Against Income Inequalities
- Citigroup Vote Not the Start of a Trend
- The True Lessons of the Great Recession
- Why Being 'On The Right Track' Isn't Enough
- The Most Lopsided Economic Recovery On Record
- The Far-Reaching Effects of the Generational Wealth Gap
- Maybe the Young Aren't Taking Over the 1 Percent
- Slipping Chinese Growth Could Hurt U.S. Exports
- Mortgage Lending Lags Pick-Up in Consumer Credit
- Where We Dwell Is Changing Fast
- How 'Shadow Inventory' Hurts the Housing Market
- 3 Reasons Not to Panic About the March Jobs Report
- How Long Will the Pain at the Pump Last?
- Is Your Bank To Blame for Pain at the Pump?
- Car Sales Soar Even as Gas Prices Do, Too
- We're Turning America into a Giant Casino
- Labor Market Showdown: The Employed vs the Unemployed
- We Are All West Now
- The Second Oil Revolution
- Invoking Fake Job Creators to Cut Taxes on the Rich
- CEOs Bullish on Economy but Will Wait and See on Jobs
- No Magic Bullet for the Price of Gas
- Bye-bye American Economic Pie
- America's Day of Reckoning is Here
- What's Good for the CEO May Be Bad for Business
- Could the Rosy Jobs Numbers Be a False Spring?
- Three Ways to Revive Our Sluggish Economy
- Consumers Still Buried In Credit Card Debt
- Job-Killing Tax Breaks
- Pumping Gas Prices for All They're Worth
- Extra Dollars You're Paying At Pump Going To Wall Street Speculators
- Why Americans Are Paying More At the Pump
- Lack of 'Rainy Day Funds' Bringing Consumers Down
- 2012 Job Gains: This Time, It's Different
- The Manufacturing Myth
- Deja View: Consumer Confidence Back Where it Was a Year Ago
- Starving Public Universities Shrinks the Middle Class
- A Farewell to Fossil Fuels
- United States Can't Control the World Oil Market
- Tensions in Middle East Fan Fears of Sharp Gas Price Hikes
- Inflation Outpacing Compensation for U.S. Workers
- The Myth of Economic Inequality
- Occupy Wall Street Must Learn That We Are What We Buy
- Six Unusual Economic Indicators
- Housing Market Improves, but Growth Years Away
- Could Strong Chinese Currency Boost U.S. Economy?
- The Downward Mobility of the American Middle Class
- Unemployment: Fudging the Numbers
- Why the Fed is Lukewarm on the Economic Recovery
- Are Student Loans the Next Debt Bomb?
Why Fairness is Essential for Economic Growth | Politics
Copyright © 2012 Tribune Media Services