Sounds like a Madden game (elite players, not typical bums on xbox live).. the reason it works in Madden is because the offense is way more effective than the defense is, so you usually can't afford to punt. The NFL is turning into an offensive game with all the rule changes, and this would eventually happen if it gets out of control. I hope it never does. The one thing I do like is that it makes stops on defense more exciting. When you get a stop on 3rd down and go out to receive a punt, it kinda feels like you're being given the ball as opposed to earning it. You also get backed up 50 or so yards. When you get a stop on 4th down, you get the ball right then and there, which is far more satisfying than getting a punt. There would have to be rule changes if this ever became popular, like shortening quarters to avoid basketball like scores. The onside kicking part is bullsh*t though.