Toothless is like "Wait, how is this even possible?" XD Anyway, new Hiccup if only because he has become more independent despite his more established bond with him. Maybe the past should team up with the future and really kick tyrant dragon butt.
Hiccup vs hiccup? I prefer.................................*two hours later*.....young Hiccup. Because he is different. Than everyone. Very much different. He isn't that tough Viking. He's just a weak boy. But he saved Berk from the Red Death and all the other dragons. Older hiccup is already grown, stronger and more self-confident. More likely to be a hero, which he obviously is and stays. Older Hiccup is hot, yes. But he did something you would expect someone like him to do in a fantasy movie. Young Hiccup did something suprising and at the same time something that you'd expect from him. But they are so much different, and they're still the same Talking Fishbone from the inside. But young Hiccup is more couragous that older Hiccup, and that's what. I find most important in a movie character. Not the looks, strength, confidence or whatever. Older Hiccup knew he could do it, because he did it before. Young Hiccup didn't. And that's why I prefer younger Hiccup.
LOL YEAH I am just like u right now XD I have a certain obsession for Hiccup right now that i juat cant wait until the movie comes im like I want it and i want it nowwww!!! my mom is like can u just SHUT UP already im tired of hearing u say that ALL day EVERY day XD! IF he was real I would TOTALLY DATE HIM 4 SURE!.