It makes sense but as long you cannot prove this, people can start asking questions an give one the feeling that something is wrong.
Like Gold can dive to 800 CAD or QIT has to do a finance and better to do it now than later!
But if they don't own the shares and also don't know noting and are make suggestive argument what could happen if.....or when, you can almost know they have a hidden agenda. There are all kinds of jokers walking around. Not important anyway.