US 7404882 B2
A miniaturized gas sensor including film type electrodes, and a solid ionomer electrolyte, for the detection of toxic gases, i.e., carbon monoxide, and other oxidizable or reducible gases and vapors is described. The all-solid planar sensor cell has two or more film type electrodes arranged on a non-conductive planar surface of a supportive material. The electrodes are discrete and in intimate contact with the same solid polymer ionomer membrane. The sensor cell contains no liquid electrolyte and is operated in a potentiostatic or potentiodynamic mode. The unique feature of the sensor cell is that high sensitivity to a select gas or vapor is achieved by a novel three-phase contact area design for a sensing electrode which is easily accessible to the gas sample via small diffusion openings or holes that penetrate through the solid polymer ionomer membrane layer above the sensing electrode. A significant signal to background noise enhancement is achieved for these film type sensor cells by processes that increase the three-phase contact area.
1. A sensor cell, comprising:
a substrate having a surface for depositing electrodes thereon;
an electrode in contact with said surface;
an ionomer membrane in contact with said substrate and having a first location and a second location;
an opening in said membrane extending from said first location to said second location proximate to said electrode; and
wherein said opening is generally non-tortuous for defining a passage for a gas to pass freely from said first location to said second location and contact said electrode within said opening.
2. The sensor cell according to
3. The sensor cell according to
4. The sensor cell according to
5. The sensor cell according to
6. The sensor cell according to
7. The sensor cell according to
8. The sensor cell according to
9. The sensor cell apparatus according to
10. The sensor cell according to
11. The sensor cell according to
12. The sensor cell according to
13. The sensor cell according to
14. The sensor cell according to
a plurality of electrode particles dispersed throughout said ionomer membrane;
wherein said opening defines a passage for a gas to pass from said first location to said second location and contact said electrode within said opening; and
wherein said plurality of electrode particles increase contact between the gas, electrode particles, and ionomer membrane.
15. The sensor cell according to
16. The sensor cell according to
17. A sensor cell, comprising:
a substrate having a surface for depositing electrodes thereon;
an electrode in contact with said surface of said substrate;
an ionomer membrane in contact with said substrate and having a first surface and a second surface;
an opening in said membrane extending from said first surface to said second surface in a location proximate to said electrode for defining a passage;
said opening is generally non-tortuous for defining a passage; and
a gas in said opening and simultaneously contacting said electrode and said ionomer membrane for providing a three-way contact between said gas, said electrode, and said ionomer membrane within said opening.
This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/443,875 for a “Film Type Solid Polymer Ionomer Sensor and Sensor Cell” filed Nov. 19, 1999, now U.S. Pat. No. 6,682,638.
The invention is in general directed toward a gas sensor and in particular to a miniaturized gas sensor with film type electrodes and a solid ionomaer electrolyte.
Film based techniques have been investigated for a wide variety of sensors, as reported by Wenyi et al., 1997; Hughes et al., 1997; Staley, 1996; Agbor et al., 1995; Tan and Tan, 1995; Menil et al., 1994; Kunnecke et al., 1994; Creasey and Varney, 1994; Geistlinger, 1993; Ishiji et al., 1993; Najafi et al., 1992; Hampp et al., 1992; Nakano and Ogawa, 1994; and Yamazoe and Miura, 1994. While solid-state gas sensors have the advantage of being able to operate at elevated temperatures, they also have the disadvantages of slow response and recovery time and a high internal operating temperature as reported by Liu et al., 1993; Narducci et al., 1993 and more recently by Schwebel et al., 1997; Sheng et al., 1997; and Micocci et al., 1997. Substantial development work needs to be done with this type of sensors before they can be utilized in battery-powered sensor instruments.
A Nafion®-coated metal oxide pH sensor was reported (Kinlen et al., 1994) with sputtered iridium oxide sensing and silver/silver chloride reference electrodes on alumina ceramic substrates. Nafion was used as a cation-selective ionomer coating in order to decrease the oxidation-reduction error generally affecting the performance of metal oxide pH electrodes. The use of Nafion as a polymer-electrolyte for a thin-film CO sensor was described (Yasuda et al., 1994) with macro-sized, sputtered Pt sensing electrodes and counter electrodes and a smaller, sputtered Au electrode as a reference electrode. A 5 wt % n-propyl alcohol solution of Nafion (DuPont, 1100 EW) was used to form the polymer electrolyte film over the electrodes by casting. The polymer was washed and protonated in aqueous sulfuric acid prior to casting. The lifetime of this sensor was reported to be less than one month. During this one month lifetime the CO oxidation current decreased steadily down to a few percent of its original value without any period of stable measurement signal. The lifetime of the device may be extended by up to three years by lamination of the polymer electrolyte layer with a cast perfluorocycloether-polymer film in order to keep the CO permeability coefficient through Nafion constant. Theoretical calculations showed that the drift rate of the signal could be significantly reduced under these conditions.
Descriptions of typical state-of-the-art hydrated solid polymer electrolyte or ionomer sensors and sensor cells are provided by Kosek et al. U.S. Pat. No. 5,527,446; LaConti and Griffith, U.S. Pat. No. 4,820,386; Shen et al., U.S. Pat. No. 5,573,648; and, Stetter and Pan, U.S. Pat. No. 5,331,310. These sensor cells, based on hydrated solid polymer electrolyte or ionomer technology, have several advantages over conventional electrochemical sensor cells. The catalytic electrodes are bonded directly to both sides of a proton conducting solid polymer ionomer membrane providing a stable electrode to electrolyte interface. One side of the electrolyte membrane is flooded with distilled water, making the sensor cell self-humidifying and independent of external humidity. Since no corrosive acids or bases are used in the sensor cell, over 10 years lifetime has been demonstrated for solid polymer ionomer sensor cells. Finally, the sensor cells are easy to maintain, thus ideal for use in remote, unattended environments. Regular addition of water to the reservoir in the sensor housing every several months, and monthly calibration checks are the only requirements.
A disadvantage of the state-of-the-art sensors described above is that the signal-to-noise ratio may not be conducive to the detection of very low concentrations (parts per billion, ppb) of important environmental and biomedical gases and vapors. Also, response time may be relatively slow, and reproducibility between sensors and sensor cells may be difficult to achieve. The sensors are also relatively costly.
The objective of this invention is to overcome the present limitations of miniaturized electrochemical sensors by uniquely interfacing advanced solid polymer ionomer membrane configurations with film type electrode structures to obtain low maintenance, highly sensitive, rapidly responsive, reproducible, sensor devices for environmental, industrial, and biomedical monitoring. By using a uniquely designed film type electrode array in intimate contact with an advanced solid polymer ionomer membrane film configuration, to form a three-phase contact area for the sensing electrode, where the gas sample, the electrode, and the solid ionomer can interface, a superior signal-to-noise ratio, rapid response time, and reproducibly of at least 1 to 10 ppb for a selected gas in an ambient environment can be achieved. Also, the projected cost of these sensors and sensor cells is very low since established film type solid-state manufacturing processes can be utilized.
The invention is also directed toward a treatment process for catalytically activating an ionomer membrane.
The invention is still further directed toward a gas sensor utilized in conjunction with a gas sensor control circuit.
The invention is also directed toward a gas sensor utilized in a gas sensing instrument.
The film type sensor cell assembly shown in the schematic drawing of
Alternatively the openings in the ionomer membrane (6) can be slits or other suitable configurations for interfacing to form a three-phase contact area (2). Also, in order to enhance the magnitude of the signal response and long-term stability, alternative materials such as Pt, gold, RuO2 or other select metal or metal oxides can be deposited within the ionomer membrane (5) as finely dispersed particles.
Some select film type electrode configurations on non-conductive planar surfaces of a supporting material (11), i.e., of alumina substrates, are showing practical sensing (3), counter (8) and reference (7) electrode design in
A block diagram of the complete film type gas or vapor sensing instrument (12) is shown in
The film type gas or vapor sensing instrument (12), which is shown in
The novelty of the measurement process is that it features potential (voltage) control as well as diffusion control through openings (6) in the membrane (5) of the sensor cell (1) for the sensitive and reproducible measurement of gas or vapor. The potential-control circuit (13) (potentiostat) maintains the sensing electrode (3) at a fixed potential above the reference electrode (7) by passing current between the sensing (3) and counter electrode (8). All three electrodes are located on the same surface of solid polymer ionomer (5). A typical potentiostatic circuit for maintaining the sensing electrode (3) at a fixed potential versus a Pt/air (O2) reference (7) is shown in
The control amplifier portion (17 b) of the sensor control circuit (13) consists of a micro power operational amplifier (e.g., MAX407 or LM6062). The sensing (3), counter (8) and reference (7) electrode portions of the sensor assembly (1) are in the feedback loop of the control amplifier (17 b) as shown in
The resulting sensor cell (1) current (flow of electrons from (3) to (8)), which is linearly related to the concentration of gas, is transformed into a voltage signal by the current-to-voltage converter (15 a). Temperature compensation of the sensor signal is effected in the next stage of amplification (15 b) using a thermistor (18 a) which is positioned in the gas sensor plastic housing (10). The last stage of amplification (15 c) provides the necessary inversion of the voltage signal as well as gain adjustment, to permit calibration for normal variations in sensitivity among sensors. The same type of micro power operational amplifier is used for these stages (15 a), (15 b), (15 c) as for the control amplifier (15 b). The transformed current signal is directed to an A/D channel on the data acquisition board of the microprocessor (14).
Power for the sensor control circuit (13) is provided by a Duracell 6-V battery (16 d) (PX 28A or 28L) through a micro power-regulated power supply (16). The power supply (16) utilizes a voltage inverter (e.g., ICL 7660) (16 a) to convert the positive battery voltage to a negative voltage of the same magnitude, and a positive voltage regulator (e.g., MAX663) (16 c) and negative voltage regulator (e.g., MAX 664) (16 b) to provide a stable ±3.9 volts.
Other embodiments may include protonic as well as anionic-hydroxide ion-exchange solid ionomer membrane—film type configurations, containing the three-phase contact area (2), and can be used to detect important environmental and biomedical gases and vapors including CO, ozone, NO, NO2, H2S, SO2, CO2, hydrogen, hydrazine, ammonia, ethanol, and acetone. Other easily oxidizable or reducible gases such as Cl2, HCl, formaldehyde, ethylene, or acetylene are readily detected at very low levels.
FIG. 2-a, shows an embodiment comprising a band-type film type sensing electrode (19), 0.5×4 mm2 in size, between two 2×4 mm2 rectangular counter electrode (8) structures. Two additional electrodes are included in the design, serving as reference electrodes (7). The electrode closest to the sensing electrode (19) is used as Pt/air reference electrode (7). The film type counter (8) and reference (7) electrodes are electroplated with Pt black to increase their actual surface area. When a Pt sensing electrode (19) is desired, it is also electroplated with Pt black to increase the measured current signal. A Nafion membrane, approximately 4.5 mil thick, is mechanically pressed onto the electrodes through a specially designed sensor housing (10). A single opening (6) in the ionomer membrane (5), approximately 1.0 mm in diameter provides gas access to the novel three-phase contact area (2), where oxidation/reduction of the analyte occurs. The analyte stream is directed over the sensing electrode (2) at moderately low flow rates. The analyte diffuses on to the sensing electrode (2) through a diffusion hole (20) in the sensor housing (10) and membrane (5) which has length-to-diameter ratios of approximately 3 or greater.
According to the present invention, band-type film type sensing electrodes (19) are used to measure most environmental gases, including ozone, SO2, NO2, and CO. Gold sensing electrodes are used when measuring ozone and NO2 and Pt sensing electrodes are used when measuring SO2 and CO. Calibration curves obtained with this design for ozone, SO2, NO2, and CO are shown in
FIG. 2-b, shows an embodiment comprising a flag-type film type sensing electrode (21), 6×6 mm2, surrounded by a U-shaped counter electrode (8); with a rectangular 1×4.5 mm2 reference electrode (7) located below the sensing electrode (21). Flag-type film type sensing electrodes (21) are used to measure ozone, NO and CO. Gold sensing electrodes are used to measure ozone and NO, while Pt electrode is used to measure CO. The film type counter (8) and reference (7) electrodes are electroplated with Pt black, as well as the sensing electrode (21), when a Pt sensing electrode is desired. As in the embodiment in FIG. 2-a, the solid ionomer electrolyte (5) is mechanically pressed onto the film type electrodes through a specially designed housing (10). Six openings in the membrane (6), approximately 1.0 mm dia. each, expose the three-phase contact areas (2) to the gas sample (4) under investigation. The film type sensor assembled in the specially designed housing (10) is placed in a 40-ml-volume diffusion chamber, to which the analyte is introduced, to simulate oxidation/reduction of the analyte under static flow conditions. The analyte (4) diffuses on to the sensing electrode (21) through six diffusion openings through the hardware (20) and membrane (6), each opening having a total length-to-diameter ratio of approximately 3 or greater.
Calibration curves for ozone, NO and CO are shown in
The flag-type film type sensing electrode (21) design can be utilized to measure ethanol, methanol, acetone, hydrazine and hydrogen. Potentiostatic-controlled measurement results for the above mentioned gases are listed in Table-1.
Dot-type film type sensing electrodes (22) are used to measure NH3 and H2S. Potentiostatically controlled measurement results for the above mentioned gases are listed in Table 2.
Further embodiments of this invention include utilizing laser ablation methods for creating openings in the ionomer membrane in addition to the traditional methods of die punching. These openings may be of any appropriate shape. A diffusion barrier membrane may be placed over the openings to achieve permeation selectivity. Additionally, a filter material such as Purafil may be placed over, or in, the openings to remove interfering gasses or contaminants. Various heat or bonding methods may be employed for placing the ionomer film or membrane on the film type electrodes or the film type substrates.
The signal response of the three phase contact area can be enhanced through the use of a porous ionomer membrane film over the sensing electrode. Porosity can be achieved by utilizing a casting film of liquid ionomer that contains easily leachable fillers such as starch or polyglycols.
The sensing electrodes can be organized in multiple arrays or sets containing a necessary number of counter or reference electrodes. Reference electrodes such as Pt/air (O2), PtO2, or dynamic hydrogen electrode as described by Giner (1964) may be employed. Electrically driven 3- or 2-electrode film type configurations may be employed using potentiostatic, potentiodynamic or potential control. Two-electrode configurations require a reversible or stable counter-reference electrode such as Pt/air (O2), PtO2 or Pt/H2 which has a higher BET (Brunauer, Emmett, Teller) surface area (25 m2/g or larger) and/or larger geometric surface areas than the sensing electrode.
Electrochemically reversible electrodes may be used in 3 or 2 electrode configurations, but especially in a 2 electrode arrangement where the counter electrode also acts as a reference electrode. Electrochemically reversible electrodes are constructed of stable catalyst materials and usually have a relatively large electrochemical active surface area so that they remain stable and their potential is not perturbed by small current flow. Examples include PtO2 and Ag/AgCl electrodes.
The sensor may be operated in a potentiodynamic mode of operation which serves to restore the original surface of the sensing electrode after gas or vapor sample adsorbs or perturbs the nature of the surface.
The sensor may also be used to detect other gases or vapors that are easily oxidizable or reducible, such as aldehydes (formaldehyde, acetaldehyde), Cl2, HCl, ethylene, acetylene.