The Case against Windfarms
The Case Against Windfarms is an authoritive, referenced document written by Dr John Etherington ( © Dr JR Etherington).
11. House prices, tourism and jobs
It is little more than a matter of common sense to realise that wind power may seriously affect property price. Given two identical rural houses, one with wind turbines on its horizon, in which would you invest your £200k? There is but one answer unless ‘green’ commitment has displaced all sense.
What 'they' say
"Myth: Wind farms devastate house prices” DTI Myths
A study of its members’ opinions by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS 2004) concluded that "60% of the sample suggested that wind farms decrease the value of residential properties where the development is within view...” and the report also concluded that “Once a wind farm is completed, the negative impact on property values continues but becomes less severe after two years or so after completion"
With outrageous misrepresentation, the DTI Myths website (above) dishonestly misquotes the RICS survey findings: - “A study by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors suggests that wind farms have no lasting impact on UK house prices” and continues “It shows that local house prices recover from any initial impact once a wind farm has been operating for two years.” Compare that with the very different original versions above!
DTI Myths then compounds the offence by writing “People promoting fears of falling prices risk making them self- fulfilling." I am sure that this was not the interpretation arrived at by the district judge who awarded substantial compensation to a family from Marton in
A valuer in mid-Wales has suggested a probable 25% reduction in house value caused by a proposed windfarm (Remax E.A. 2005) and at Lethbridge in Devon, two independent valuers predicted that a farm property will similarly lose £165,000 in value (Sunday Telegraph January 2005).
The wind power industry vehemently denies such impacts but facts and common sense speak louder than their words
Just as common sense predicts that wind power will influence property price it seems equivalently likely that it will deflect the rural tourist who comes for peace and quiet, to escape the constant movement and noise of the city and to recharge their mental batteries.
The deeply disturbing thing is that the wind power industry refutes this by saying there is no “proof” of impact on house prices, but unfortunately this is a classic Catch-22 situation in which the proof is the damnation – it will be too late and the precautionary principle is the only safe approach.
Whether we like it or not, tourism is the future for rural
What 'they' say
Myth: Wind farms keep tourists away: Many wind farms are tourist attractions.” DTI Myths
The fact that the Gaia Centre at Delabole went bankrupt, the Swaffham eco-centre encountered serious financial troubles and Cold Northcott visitor centre near Delabole was forced to close, might just be bad luck or rotten management! Interestingly most of the wind ‘farms’ which are claimed to be tourist attraction are in fact visitor centres in their own right, all in areas where tourists are seeking indoor occupation in bad weather. The Wales Tourist Board summed-this up perfectly “… there will only be a need for a very small number of wind farm visitor centres before this also reaches saturation point. The WTB believe that the case for wind farms as tourist attractions in their own right only has very limited appeal.” (Letter to author from WTB May 2002).
The impact of wind power on tourism may in fact be substantial. In 2003 the Wales Tourist Board concluded from a survey of businesses in mid-Wales that "Just over half of the respondents thought wind farms have already and will continue to have an adverse effect on visitors coming to the area." And we have not even started building a lot of big ones yet!
A survey in the Western Isles arrived at a similar disturbing conclusion (Tourism Operators in North West Lewis, 2004).
What ‘they’ say
Wind energy is the fastest growing energy sector in the
Reality. During construction of Causey Mire wind ‘farm’,
Reality. In March 2002, Merfyn Williams CPRW said (in the Western Mail) that the tourism and leisure industry in
Thus, though wind ‘farms’ threaten to destroy jobs in the tourist industry; they create few if any compensating jobs elsewhere.
The simple truth is that if the subsidies going into renewables were diverted to other CO2-conservative projects, thousands of jobs would be created at a stroke, and far more emissions would be saved. For example Connah's Quay gas-fired power station (1400 MW) created or secured 8,000 jobs, and all of the 500 contractors and consultants were based in the
Relevant articles, news items, papers, reports
Letters from estate agents and solicitors relating to property transaction impacted by the proximity of wind farms