Behind the buzz and beyond the hype:
Our Nanowerk-exclusive feature articles
Posted: Jul 21, 2010
Harmless natural nanoparticles show potential to replace metal-based nanoparticles in sunscreen
(Nanowerk Spotlight) Quite a lot of nanotechnology research and manufacturing efforts go into synthesizing metal-based nanoparticles. Unfortunately, some of the nanoparticle manufacturing processes themselves (see: "Not so 'green' nanotechnology manufacturing") as well as the final nanoparticle materials may be of potential concern for environmental regulators and for researchers attempting to address nanomaterial toxicity. As an alternative to using these potentially hazardous metal-based nanoparticles, some researchers are suggesting the use of naturally occurring nanoparticles. However, this area has not yet been well explored with regard to natural nanoparticles' diverse properties and potential applications.
Researchers have now made the discovery that naturally occurring nanoparticles have unique optical properties. In addition, they are less toxic and biodegradable than their synthesized, metal-based counterparts. This discovery makes it likely that scientists will be able to find more biocompatible nanoparticles to replace metal-based nanoparticles, predominantly for biomedical applications.
"The concern for the biosafety and health risk for the metal-based and engineered nanoparticles in sunscreens has led to the search for alternative replacement nanoparticles," Mingjun Zhang, an Associate Professor of Biomedical Engineering at the University of Tennessee, tells Nanowerk. "In our recent study we investigated naturally occurring ivy nanoparticles to replace titanium dioxide and zinc oxide that are currently widely used in sunscreen products. Based on experimental data, we have demonstrated that ivy nanoparticles have the potential levels of UV protection, and a much lesser level of cell toxicity than metal nanoparticles, necessary to warrant further investigation for uses in cosmetics."
The morphologies of ivy nanoparticles observed by AFM. (Image: Dr. Zhang, University of Tennessee)
"Natural nanoparticles can be used as functional materials just as artificial nanoparticles" says Zhang. "Take for instance sunscreen. Here, organic and inorganic nanoparticles with ultraviolet extinction properties are widely used. The inorganic nanoparticles – such as titanium dioxide and zinc oxide – and organic nanoparticles can reflect, absorb and scatter the solar light and thus provide the sunblock effect. However, although inorganic nanoparticles have been widely used in cosmetic products, there are still concerns about the toxicity of these inorganic materials."
According to the researchers, natural or biological nanoparticles have not been investigated in detail for their material properties. In this recent study, the University of Tennessee team investigates these type nanoparticles as the functional materials just like usual inorganic and organic nanoparticles.
Zhang notes that the ivy nanoparticles are not monodisperse in solutions. "This effect is due to the biological process of the nanoparticle formation" he says. "Nanoparticles from the original tiny ones to the mature ones all exit in the rootlets of ivy. We used size exclusion chromatography (SEC) and high-performance liquid chromatography (SEC-HPLC) to isolate the nanoparticles from the mixed solutions including molecules."
This means that one area of future investigation needs to explore effective methods to obtain monodisperse ivy nanoparticles. The modifications of ivy nanoparticles to improve the optical properties are also expected. Zhang says that the team will also explore potential coatings for solar panel.
This makes it likely that if nature-derived harmless organic nanoparticles have strong ultraviolet absorption, they will be a potential promising alternative for sunscreen.
Quite impressively, the team's study indicates that ivy nanoparticles can improve the extinction of ultraviolet light at least four times better than its metal counterparts.
Zhang points out that sunscreens made with ivy nanoparticles may not need to be reapplied after swimming. "That's because the plant's nanoparticles are a bit more adhesive so sunscreens made with them may not wash off as easily as traditional sunscreens," he says. "And while sunscreens made with metal-based nanoparticles give the skin a white tinge, sunscreens made with ivy nanoparticles are virtually invisible when applied to the skin."