Superman Returns was a terrible film and it seems like the writer they're interviewing knows the faults of it pretty well. Singer made a boring film that was a sequal to the boring Donner films (I've never understood why so many people like those films).
I'm with you there. Returns
is only decent, but while the Donner movies have fantastic elements
, the films as films are bloated, dramatically inert, tonally scattershot, did I mention bloated, and vapid.