Finding that UBH abused its discretion in the handling of the plaintiffs' claims, the court explained that the proper remedy is a remand to UBH to consider all of the evidence. "Our remand, however, does not provide the plan administrator the opportunity to reevaluate a claim based on a rationale not raised in the administrative record, and not previously conveyed to Plaintiffs." (cleaned up). Because the remand to UBH is not an award of benefits, the court vacated the attorneys' fee award, which can be reconsidered after UBH properly reconsiders the claims.