LANSING, MI -- Criticism of Gov. Rick Snyder's deal to make Enbridge shut down its controversial Line 5 pipeline under the Straits of Mackinac during high waves didn't just come from the public at the state's Dec. 11 pipeline board meeting. It also came from the board itself. The Pipeline Safety Advisory Board rebuked the governor with formal resolutions asking for deal revisions, a new analysis of pipeline alternatives and a shutdown order until damage to the dual pipeline's protective coating can be repaired. The surprise resolutions, led by Jennifer McKay, Mike Shriberg, Craig Hupp, Chris Shepler and backed by Homer Mandoka, passed partly thanks to seven abstention votes by members representing the state, Enbridge and the oil & gas industry. Due to the number of abstentions, Jeffrey Pillon was a lone 'no' vote on the resolution to shut Line 5 down until repairs are made.